2015/16 News & Events
PhD Scholarship in Wiser Healthcare
Novel imaging, biomarkers and genomic tests for risk assessment and early disease detection are changing how medicine is practiced in Australia and internationally. While delivering valuable advances in care and benefits for patients and their families, these new and emerging diagnostics can also have important negative consequences – overdiagnosis and overtreatment. Overdiagnosis occurs when commonly-used diagnoses in health and medical care, diagnoses that relevant health professionals would consider correct, do more harm than good. Overtreatment, which generally follows overdiagnosis, occurs when people get treatment they don’t need. We are seeking to fund a PhD candidate who is interested in working with a multidisciplinary team to answer the question: What can be done to prevent overdiagnosis and overtreatment?
The PhD candidacy is based at VELiM, University of Sydney and associated with an NHMRC-funded Centre for Research Excellence (CRE), Wiser Healthcare.
Details are at: http://agile2.ucc.usyd.edu.au/ro/opportunities/scholarships/1784.
Further information can be obtained from .
Film Screening and Panel Discussion
7 November 2016, 6.45pm
The film: "The Interrogation"; more information on the film including trailer and tickets
Panelists: A/Prof Michael Robertson (Panel Chair), psychiatrist, academic and Visiting Professorial Fellow, Sydney Jewish Museum; Prof Angus Dawson, VELiM Director, and Dr Avril Alba, Lecturer in Holocaust Studies and Jewish Civilisation, Department of Hebrew, Biblical and Jewish Studies, University of Sydney, and Sydney Jewish Museum. More information on the panel discussion.
Tickets available at the JIFF Website.
Organisers: VELiM in association with the 2016 Jewish International Film Festival, Sydney
Venue and date: Event Cinemas, Bondi Junction, NSW, 7 Nov 2016, starting at 6.45pm
Symposium: Conflicts of Interest in Healthcare
31 October 2016, 1-5pm
This symposium brings together a multi-disciplinary group of scholars to explore the ethical and policy implications of financial and non-financial conflicts of interest in medicine and public health. Four sessions will address conceptual and practical implications of conflicts of interest from clinical, policy, scientific and academic perspectives.
Organisers: VELiM, CAVE (Macquarie University), and the Bias and Research Integrity group (University of Sydney)
Venue: Medical Foundation Building, Sparkes Street, Camperdown, NSW 2050
Attendance is free but registration required via Eventbrite. For more information download the event flier.
Tuberculosis: Ethics, Law & Society
18 October 2016, 9am to 5pm
Tuberculosis prevention, control and treatment is often the subject of contention and debate. How should we respond when an individual chooses not to undergo lengthy treatment because they are worried about possibly serious side-effects? What are the implications of focusing on TB reduction and elimination given the concentration of this disease in disadvantaged and marginalised groups? How do TB patients feel? What are their experiences of TB treatment? How should we understand, and what can we learn from, the history of TB policy? What ethical issues arise from new drug developments and diagnostics? How do co-infection with HIV and TB and new forms of drug resistance create new problems, and how should we respond? - This workshop will explore Tuberculosis from many different perspectives, including ethics, law, human rights, sociology, history and anthropology. Speakers will discuss aspects of their own research and how these are of key relevance to thinking about Tuberculosis today and in the future.
Confirmed speakers include Dr Chris Degeling, Dr Bridget Haire, Dr Susan Hemer, Dr Paul Mason, Nola Ries, A/Prof Diego Silva and Prof Ross Upshur.
Organisers: Prof Angus Dawson and Kelly Prendergast
Venue: Centenary Institute, Missenden Road, Sydney
Attendance is free but registration required via Eventbrite.
Human Rights and Medical Goods Supply Chains: Working towards a healthier future
9 September 2016, 12 - 1pm
A panel discussion presented by The Healthy Supply Chains Initiative in partnership with VELiM.
The Healthy Supply Chains Initiative is a group working towards the ethical and responsible supply of medical goods in Australia. At present, many of the goods used in hospitals, clinics and aged care facilities around the country are produced in appalling conditions. Workers are poorly remunerated and routinely deprived of their labour rights and basic human rights. In many instances child labour is being used. The Healthy Supply Chains Initiative aims to enact effective supply chain regulation for medical goods. Precedents in Sweden and the United Kingdom have shown that ethical oversight can be incorporated into workplace procurement policies and government legislation and that making these changes is not only beneficial for the people producing medical goods, but is also low risk and low cost for procurers.
Guest speaker: Dr Mahmood Bhutta
Panel Moderator: Prof Angus Dawson
Venue: The Australian Human Rights Commission, Level 3, 175 Pitt St, Sydney NSW 2000
Date: Friday, 9 September 2016, 12 - 1pm
Please register your attendance with Katherine Moloney. Places are limited. For more information download the event flier.
A/Prof Stacy Carter wins research fellowship
Congratulations to A/Prof Stacy Carter who has been awarded a funded research fellowship to visit the Policy, Ethics and Life Sciences (PEALS) Research Centre at the University of Newcastle, UK in 2017.
A/Prof Ainsley Newson wins Sydney Medical School Accelerator Award
August 2016: A/Prof Ainsley Newson is one of eleven outstanding mid-career teaching and research academics who won the inaugural Sydney Medical School Accelerator Award 2016. The Accelerator scheme provides funding of $50k to contribute to the research costs of projects currently in progress. Congratulations!
Whose mind is it, anyway? A conversation about the neuroethics of cognitive ageing
18 August 2016, 12-1pm
Neuroethics can be used as a lens to examine the ethical and social issues that arise from the recent prioritization of brain health to prevent age-related cognitive decline in the ageing population. Key topics of this seminar will be the role of neurotechnology and the balance of individual responsibility and collective benefits in delaying cognitive ageing.
Presenter: Dr Cynthia Forlini, ARC DECRA Research Fellow at VELiM
Venue: Brain and Mind Research Institute, Lecture Theatre, Level 5 Building F 94 Mallett St map
More information can be requested from Ed Hendriks
John McPhee Seminar 2016: What is the point? Bioethics, agitation and ‘getting in the way’
1 August 2016, 12-1pm
This presentation will focus on Harvard University psychologist Prof Steven Pinker's views on The Moral Imperative for Bioethics and open a conversation about the ‘point’ of bioethics. Pinker’s central thesis raises a series of important questions regarding the manner in which bioethics is functioning, the role that it should play – in research, practice, education and policy-making, and whether, in fact, contra Pinker’s anxiety, it is ever ‘in the way.’
Presenter: Ian Kerridge Professor of Bioethics and Medicine at VELiM, Staff Haematologist/Bone Marrow Transplant physician at Royal North Shore Hospital, Sydney, and founding member of The Clinical Unit in Ethics and Health Law (CUEHL). For more information please email Camilla Scanlan.
Ainsley Newson edits special issue of Australasian Science
A/Prof Ainsley Newson has guest-edited the July/August 2016 special issue of Australasian Science, an Australian monthly science magazine for the general public. The issue, Genomics, is dedicated to ethical and social issues in genomics. It includes several articles written or co-written by VELiM-staff, including A/Prof Ainsley Newson, Dr Wendy Lipworth, Dr Paul Mason, Dr Jacqueline Savard, Prof Ian Kerridge and Dr Tereza Hendl. Topics include: Genomic Testing as a Lifetime Health Resource?, The Ethics of Online Genomics Tests, Biobanks Go Global, and The Stem Cell “Sell”. The special issue is currently on sale at Newsagents.
Wiser Healthcare Research Collaboration
Funded by two related grants from the National Health and Medical Council (NHMRC), a group of collaborating researchers from the University of Sydney, Bond University, Monash University and international colleagues launched Wiser Healthcare, a collaboration which aims to conduct research that will reduce overdiagnosis and overtreatment in Australia and around the world.
☛ More information on Wiser Healthcare
☛ More information on overdiagnosis
Sydney Ideas Events:
17 May 2016: Defending the Aussie Mozzie
The Marie Bashir Institute in partnership with the Human Animal Research Network present a panel discussion on issues relating to the recent Zika outbreak and relevant broader, contextual features of human-mosquito relations. Questions of interest include: Is Zika a threat in Australia? What other threats are there to human health from mosquito-borne disease? Why are such threats growing rather than receding? What do we know about how human behaviour influences mosquitoes, and vice-versa?
- Dr Cameron Webb, Clinical Lecturer, Marie Bashir Institute of Infectious Diseases and Biosecurity, University of Sydney
- A/Prof Tess Lea, Department of Gender and Cultural Studies, University of Sydney
- Prof Angus Dawson, Director of the Centre for Values, Ethics and the Law in Medicine
The Discussion will be moderated by Chris Degeling from the Centre for Values, Ethics and the Law in Medicine.
Date and Venue: 17 May 2016, 6.00pm - 7.30pm, Law School Annex, University of Sydney
30 May 2016: Is Too Much Testing and Treatment Making us Sick?
Sydney Ideas in partnership with the Sydney School of Public Health present a panel discussion on modern medical tests - imaging, biomarkers and genetic tests. Done in the right way at the right time, they can be lifesaving, and in the past often have been. But might they have become too good? Could some tests now be leading too much diagnosis and too much treatment? If so, what’s driving this? What might the consequences be for individual citizens, patients, their families and health care systems? And how can we fix it?
- Dr Iona Heath, retired London-based GP, past president of the Royal College of General Practitioners
- Prof Chris Semsarian, Sydney Medical School and Head of the Molecular Cardiology Program, Centenary Institute
- Prof Jenny Doust, Bond University
- Prof Ian Kerridge, Centre for Values Ethics and the Law in Medicine
- Prof Kirsten McCaffery, Sydney School of Public Health
- A/Prof Stacy Carter, Centre for Values, Ethics and the Law in Medicine
- Prof Alexandra Barratt, Sydney School of Public Health
New book: Public Health Ethics: Cases Spanning the Globe
Prof Angus Dawson is one of the editors of the new book Public Health Ethics: Cases Spanning the Globe. The collection contains background material and cases from public health policy and practice with contributions from twenty-three different countries.
The book highlights ethical issues and dilemmas that arise in the practice of public health. It is a tool to support instruction, debate, and dialogue regarding public health ethics. Although the practice of public health has always included consideration of ethical issues, the field of public health ethics as a discipline is a relatively new and emerging area. There are few practical training resources for public health practitioners, especially resources which include discussion of realistic cases which are likely to arise in the practice of public health. This work discusses these issues on a case to case basis and helps create awareness and understanding of the ethics of public health care. The main audience for the casebook are public health practitioners, including front-line workers, field epidemiology trainers and trainees, managers, planners, and decision makers who have an interest in learning about how to integrate ethical analysis into their day to day public health practice. The book is also useful to schools of public health and public health students as well as to academic ethicists who can use the book to teach public health ethics and distinguish it from clinical and research ethics.
The whole book is downloadable for free.
Holocaust Film Screenings and Panel Discussion
Two film screenings with panel discussions co-presented by the Centre for Values, Ethics and the Law in Medicine and the Sydney Jewish Museum in association with the 2016 Holocaust Film Series.
FILM 1: A Nazi Legacy: What Our Fathers Did
Date: Monday, 2 May 2016, 7:30pm
A Jewish human rights lawyer confronts the sons of high ranking Nazi officials who bear witness to their father’s actions, their guilt and implicitness in the Nazi regime.
More information about the film, trailer, and tickets and about the panel discussion
FILM 2: Claude Lanzmann: Spectres of the Shoah
Date: Tuesday 3 May 2016, 8pm
An exploration of the 12-year journey undertaken by French director Claude Lanzmann to make his 1985 film Shoah, a nine-and-a-half-hour-long documentary about the Holocaust.
New Children’s book
Paul published this book on World TB day, 24 March 2016. Copies of the book will be distributed to 120 villages in Ca Mau, the southernmost province of Vietnam. The book has been published in English, Vietnamese, Tagalog, French and Portuguese, with more translations in the pipeline.
A beautifully written and illustrated children’s book that educates children about the symptoms, diagnosis and treatment of tuberculosis. This book will help to encourage children with TB and their families to seek treatment, and decrease the stigma associated with this disease. - Dr Jennifer Ho, Woolcock Institute of Medical Research, Vietnam.
The audiobook is available on soundcloud. The book is also available in PDF-format (English version).
Sydney Ideas: BALL & Other Funny Stories About Cancer
Date: 14 March 2016
Venue: Seymour Centre, Cnr of City Rd and Cleveland St, Chippendale, University of Sydney
Drawing from ten years of monologues and spoken word performances, Brian Lobel presents an hour of humorous, provocative, interactive and thoughtful reflections on a history of cancer and the patient experience. - A Sydney Ideas event at the Seymour Centre co-presented with VELiM, the School of Public Health, and the Department of Theatre and Performance Studies, all University of Sydney.
Special Presentation: "Unfathomable Journeys"
Date: 23 February 2016
Venue: Sydney Jewish Museum, 148 Darlinghurst Road, Darlinghurst NSW 2010
Fifty years ago, eminent physician Dr Otto Walter abandoned life in Australia to return to Austria, leaving his crestfallen young grandson, Garry, to wonder why he had gone. - In this lecture, Professor Garry Walter AM explores the possible reasons for his grandfather’s departure, weaving in aspects of Otto’s extraordinary life, including his flight from Vienna after Kristallnacht, and his struggles to stay one step ahead of the Nazis in Europe. Otto was to settle in Palestine (later Israel), before coming to Australia in 1949 on the Cyrenia – serving as the ship’s doctor for Jewish refugees. In Australia, the consummate medical skills that had proven life-saving for Otto’s family, were not formally recognised, marking the end of a distinguished career.
Warwick Anderson receives History and Philosophy of Science Medal
8 Feb 2016:
Professor Warwick Anderson is being awarded the 2015 Royal Society of New South Wales History and Philosophy of Science Medal.
Structures of survival: Managing emerging infectious diseases in the twenty first century
Date: Thursday, 10 December 2015
Time: 1.30pm - 7.00pm
Venue: New Law School, University of Sydney Main Campus
The outbreak of Ebolavirus disease, which spread widely across three West African nations in 2014, and the delay and subsequent difficulty controlling it, offered a sobering preview of the potential impacts of other emerging or drug resistant infectious diseases in the twenty first century. This symposium will examine how socioeconomic, cultural and political systems contribute to the emergence, transmission and control of infectious diseases. Instead of focusing on pathogens and infection control measures, this symposium will explore the contexts that contribute to infectious disease outbreaks and to surviving them.
The symposium will be concluded by the public forum Surviving Ebola: facing the challenge with Professor Angus Dawson (Making good decision for West Africa) and Professor Catherine Womack (Ebola and health policy).
Medical Ethics in the Shadow of the Holocaust
Date: 15 November 2015
Time: 9.30am - 4.30pm
Venue: Sydney Jewish Museum, 148 Darlinghurst Road, Darlinghurst NSW 2010
A seminar for medical and healthcare practitioners, students and scholars presented by the Centre for Values, Ethics and the Law in Medicine and the Sydney Jewish Museum.
Join academics and physicians in examining the evolution of medical ethics and the relationship between the profession and the state. Does the moral low point in the history of medicine provide guidance for today’s quandaries in medical ethics? What is the place of euthanasia and eugenics in contemporary society? - Participants will have the opportunity to engage with living witnesses to genocide.
A certificate of completion will be provided for CME points.
Early bird admission (until 30 Sept): $175
General admission: $195 (light lunch included)
Student concession: available on request
'Ich Klage An' - Film Screening and Discussion
Date: 7 October 2015
Time: 7:00 pm
Venue: Sydney Jewish Museum, 148 Darlinghurst Road, Darlinghurst NSW 2010
The Sydney Jewish Museum and the Centre for Values, Ethics and the Law in Medicine present 'Ich Klage An' ['I accuse'].
Under Nazism, members of the German public and medical profession enabled the systematic murder of the mentally and physically disabled. For the first time in Australia, see the film that sought to convince so many Germans of the program’s legitimacy…
Join us for a screening of the film followed by a special panel discussion featuring:
- Professor Miles Little (Founding Director of VELiM)
- Professor Ron McCallum (Emeritus Professor, Faculty of Law, The University of Sydney)
- Professor Dany Celemajer (Department of Sociology and Social Policy, The University of Sydney)
- Facilitated by Dr Avril Alba (Lecturer in Holocaust Studies and Jewish Civilization at the University of Sydney)
Ian Kerridge receives NHMRC Ethics Award 2015
22 September 2015: Congratulations to Associate Professor Ian Kerridge on receiving the NHMRC Ethics Award 2015. It's a mighty achievement.
The NHMRC citation:
"Associate Professor Kerridge has spent his entire career dissecting ethical issues in health practice and policy and promoting high ethical standards in health care and research. He was a member of the Legislation Review Committee that examined human cloning and the use of human embryos, and most recently, was a member of the Australian Health Ethics Committee and the Assisted Reproductive Technology Committee"
Reclaiming the Knowledge Commons: The Ethics of Academic Publishing and the Futures of Research
Date: Wednesday, 26 August 2015
Time: 9am – 4:30pm
Venue: State Library of New South Wales, Macquarie St, Sydney NSW 2000
Program: The symposium will comprise four sessions:
- Corporatisation and the commercialisation of knowledge
- Democratizing knowledge or selling the farm? The emergence and challenges of ‘Open Access’
- Dissolving barriers – and boundaries: Scholars and the possibilities of the new digital knowledge commons
- Taking up the challenge of ethical academic publication
Speakers: Emeritus Professor Stephen Leeder, Professor Paul Komesaroff, A/Professor Andrew Bonnell, Dr John Byron, JoAnne Sparks, Professor Virginia Barbour, Rosalia Garcia (SAGE), and Professor Christopher Wright