Animal Mummy Research Project

The Nicholson Museum's collection contains 14 animal mummies including cats, ibises and crocodiles from ancient Egypt. Acquired through historic archaeological excavations and individual donors, this research project aims to document and investigate the collection using multiple imagining techniques from the fields of nuclear science, medical research and 3D photography.

Votive mummies make up the largest category of objects we have from ancient Egypt and yet, until recently, have been one of the least researched. They are a particular feature of the first millennium BCE, gaining great popularity in the Late Period, increasing even more so in the Ptolemaic and Roman Periods. In much the same way as conventional offerings for the gods, votive mummies were produced for a range of budgets, from simply wrapped figures with no decorative features for the poorer (or more frugal buyer) up to lavishly wrapped mummies complete with cartonnage masks which had been mummified using an array of expensive embalming products for wealthier members of society, or perhaps, for a particularly urgent or important request.

The radiography and CT scanning examination of some mummies with external wrappings rendered to the features of specific animal species have been found to contain only part of a whole animal, or even, no skeletal material at all. The reason for these ‘fakes’ cannot be confirmed; however, it is possible that they were another legitimate form of a less expensive offering for those members of society that did not have the means for a high quality mummy, or that they were produced when few animals were available using the idea that a part of the animal could represent the whole. Another theory is that the fakes were made by the priests in order to fool the cult participants.

Through our multi-imaging approach we hope to determine the makeup of the wrapped packages and sealed containers in the collection, as well as analyse the data captured to potentially identify species, cause of death, mummification methodologies, and preservation state. Furthermore, these imaging techniques will be used to develop new museum management strategies for exhibition display, storage and conservation. Ultimately the collection of animal mummies will go on display as a key section in a new ancient Egyptian exhibition currently under development for the University's new Chau Chak Wing Museum.

About the specimens

Ibises

NM62.584

Mummified Ibis NM62.584

The Nicholson collection includes four artefacts thought to be mummified ibises, including two linen wrapped packages (NM62.584, NM62.585), one sealed ceramic jar (NMR.35) and the fragmentary remains from an opened ceramic jar (NMR.36.2). A further two ceramic jars (NM64.328, NM64.93), of unusual shape, have 'legacy data' (un-attributable commentary or data that may be erroneously linked with an artefact's record) which suggest they too may contain the remains of an ancient Egyptian ibis.

The wrapped linen packages were both acquired by the Nicholson Museum from the Egypt Exploration Society in 1914. They were found during the Society's excavations at Abydos in 1913, where zoologist Leonard Loat discovered an ibis cemetery adjacent to the human cemeteries that were under investigation. In the first two seasons of excavations (1913-14) over 150 ceramic jars and 2,500 mummified ibises were uncovered, all dated to the Roman period. The two specimens sent to Sydney are decorated with geometric burnt and resin impregnated designs.

The sealed ceramic jar and its opened counterpart were both part of Sir Charles Nicholson's founding donation of nearly 1,500 ancient Egyptian, Greek and Italian artefacts. The cone-shaped ceramics are typical of the vessels used to pack and store mummified votive ibises when they were entombed in vaults, catacombs or cemeteries related to the temples where they were left as votive offerings.

The two further jars under investigation include a small ceramic jar excavated at Abydos in 1889-1900 and donated to the Nicholson Museum by the Egypt Exploration Society, and a globular jar packed with mud to its neck which was acquired by the Nicholson Museum before 1964.

Cats

NMR.30

Mummified cat, NMR.30

The Nicholson collection includes five artefacts thought to be mummified cats. All are wrapped in linen bandages, however, they vary drastically in their size and wrapping techniques.

The two smallest wrapped packages, NM84.2 and NM84.3, were donated to the museum by Mrs Elwyn M Andrews and Miss Elizabeth C Bootle in memory of their great-uncle Sir Grafton Elliot Smith in 1984. Sir Grafton Elliot Smith was a pioneer in scientific investigations of Egyptian mummies and was one of the first people to use medical imagery (X-Rays) to investigate mummified remains. He was also the first person to obtain his MD by examination from the University of Sydney's Medical School. NM84.3 has previously undergone CT analysis in 2009, revealing the contents to be fragmentary disarticulated bones wrapped in the shape of a kitten.

NMR.30 is an adult cat, wrapped in very few bandages with the head of the animal exposed. Like two of the ibises, it was donated to the museum by Sir Charles Nicholson in 1860, and is part of the museums founding collection.

A second more ornately wrapped cat, NM62.586, was acquired by the museum before 1962. It was the subject of a CT scan in 2009, which revealed that an adult cat was preserved in this package.

One the museum's most recent acquisitions included a mummified animal thought by the donor's family to be a cat. NM2017.262 was donated by Mrs M L (Molly) St Vincent Welch in memory of Lieutenant Colonel J B St Vincent Welch DSO (1881-1919) and Dr J B St Vincent Welch (1919–1972) in 2017. Lt. Col. Welch served in the 1st Australian Field Ambulance to Egypt and Gallipoli, and commanded the 13th Australian Field Ambulance unit at the Somme, between 1914 and 1918. It is when he was stationed in Egypt that Welch collected a variety of ancient Egyptian artefacts and tourist souvenirs including the mummified 'cat'.

Crocodiles

Three baby mummified crocodiles are also found within the Nicholson collections. Two are partially wrapped in a single layer of woven linen bandages and the third is unwrapped.

The two partially wrapped specimens (NM52.406.1, NM52.406.2) were donated by Professor Richard Edwin Smith in 1952. A fragment of a baby crocodile skull (NM52.406.3) was also donated with these two items. However, due to the coverings it is not known if this head represents a third animal, or if it might join the wrapped specimen where only the tail is visible.

The unwrapped specimen, NM84.4, was also part of Sir Grafton Elliot Smith's collection and donated by his grand-nieces in his honour in 1984.

NM52.406.1

Mummified baby crocodile, NM52.406.1

Research stages

The Animal Mummy Research Project is divided into several stages, focusing on one animal type at a time. The investigation is currently in stage one of the project analysing the ibises in the collection. This stage is compiling several imaging data sets that will be used to test the validity of our approach to both known and unknown mummified remains and includes ceramic materials. The second stage will move on to investigate the cats in the collection drawing on the expertise gained in stage one of the process. The third stage will attempt to investigate the minimal crocodile specimens, for cross disciplinary access to data within the University of Sydney.

Ibis investigation - Stage 1

Neutron Tomography

ANSTO

Ibis jar in position for scanning by DINGO, at ANSTO, Lucas Heights

In 2017 Dr Conni Lord, Candace Richards and Dr Filomena Salvemini received an ANSTO cultural heritage materials grant to begin imaging five suspected ibis specimens using DINGO (neutron radiography, tomography and imaging station), at the Australian Centre for Neutron Scattering.

Neutron radiography has traditionally been used for the imagining of metallic and ceramic materials. However, this research project sought to test the viability of neutron radiography in the analysis of mummified remains and ancient Egyptian ceramics.

The five specimens analysed included the two linen wrapped packages, the sealed jar, and the two ceramic jars with mysterious data. The remains associated with the opened jar were not analysed using this technique due to their current state of preservation.

Initial results were extremely encouraging, including the quality of visualisation of the layers upon layers of linen wrappings; the detection of feather 'impressions' on the exterior of the bird within one mummified package; the confirmation of a potential ancient 'fake' within a still sealed jar from the ancient period; and the visual exclusion of two ceramics as containing animal remains.

CT imaging

CT Scanning

CT scanning the mummified ibises at UVTHS

In 2018, further sets of images of the Ibis packages in the collection were obtained using more traditional CT scanning techniques (now routinely used for the analysis of mummified remains) working with both the University of Sydney's Veterinary Teaching Hospital and the University of Sydney's new Hybrid Theatre Unit.

Working with Senior Radiographer, Helen Laurendet at The University Veterinary Teaching Hospital Sydney (UVTHS), the two linen wrapped packages were analysed using a 16-slice CT scanner. Initial readings were encouraging. Clear images of the current state of bone structure of each of the birds inside the mummified packages confirmed that an adult ibis was wrapped inside one packet and that the other contained two juveniles.

Working with Zoe Williams and Veronika Tatarinoff at the Hybrid Theatre Unit both the wrapped linen packages were scanned for a third time to compare different imaging techniques and enhanced visibility. In addition the CT scans were taken of the sealed jar and the fragmentary remains which were removed from the Ibis Jar sometime in the mid 1800s.

Analysis and Publication

Once the imaging stages of the ibis investigation are completed the different data sets will be merged for further analysis and will result in a multi-faceted 3D model of each of the specimens to not only aid our scientific study, but also for exhibition in the Chau Chak Wing Museum, opening 2020.

Conference Papers

  • F. Salvemini, "Neutron imaging, a key scientific analytical tool for the Cultural Heritage project at ANSTO" presented at 11th World Conference on Neutron Radiography 2-7 September 2018, Sydney, Australia.
  • C. Lord, F. Salvemini, F. and C. Richards, 'Old Birds, New Techniques' poster presented by C. Lord at Australasian Egyptology Conference 5, September 7-9 2018, University of Auckland, New Zealand.
  • V. Tatarinoff, C. Richards, Z. Williams, and J. Gongoria "Sacred Bin Chickens? Changing cultural perceptions in the value of animals" presented by V. Tatarinoff at Annual Australian and New Zealand Laboratory Animal Association (ANZLAA) 11-14 September 2018, Melbourne, Australia.
  • C. Lord, F. Salvemini and C. Richards, 'Ancient Birds, New Technology' presented by C. Lord at Australian History Research Seminar Series, Macquarie University. 2 October, Sydney, Australia.
  • C. Richards, C. Lord, F. Salvemini, Z Williams, and T. Harrison, 'From animal mummies to amphora - current scientific analysis of the Nicholson Museum’s classical collections' presented by C. Richards at Australasian Society for Classical Studies Annual Conference 40 (ASCS 40), 4-7 February 2019, University of New England, NSW, Australia.