Project Leadership: The game changer in large scale complex projects - report released in June 2019. Combining the expertise of ICCPM and its Series Partner, the John Grill Centre
The global importance of projects is increasing while the environment in which projects are selected, shaped, designed and delivered is becoming significantly more challenging. It is imperative that project leadership adapts to this changing context if projects are to deliver their envisioned outcomes and value.
This paradigm shift requires project leaders to be able to extend across three distinct visions of projects that reveal increasing layers of complexity: project-as-asset, project- as-system, and project-as-conversation. These visions require an increasing emotional and cognitive capacity to act from a corresponding logic as Expert, Achiever or Strategist:
The game changer in large scale complex projects is the leaders’ ability to see projects not just as assets or systems but also as conversations.
A fundamental reframing is critical and must consider the need for early and deliberate trust-building and harnessing the opportunity of social media. It also requires a dynamic view of stakeholder networks and involvement of project team members that can only be achieved by building a stakeholder-centric mindset and culture.
A project-as-conversation provides a strong foundation for reframing: a good conversation requires being present to the other person; listening; engagement; being aware and empathetic to the context, interests, fears and power of a stakeholder; and can be conducted using a range of media. All of these elements are critical to stakeholder-centricity and will help a project leader see what dynamics need to be navigated to work towards a broad perspective of value and a bigger strategic purpose.
Project management, like any other professional domain, will be disrupted by digital technology. To capitalise on these developments, we must identify Industry 4.0 ‘design principles’ that help improve how we deliver successful complex projects.
Project managers who operate from an Achiever action logic are likely to adopt any technologies that will assist to ‘get the job done’ better, faster and with less risk. However, Strategists will be less constrained and more likely able to consider how technology may change the game altogether.
Research has identified the human-to- human aspects of projects as the toughest challenges of complex project leadership and suggested a need for agility, working with resistance, inspiring others, adapting to context, being self-aware, and understanding how we are authors of our own reality.
A project-as-conversation perspective adds a layer of awareness of relational dynamics, what interests and fears lie underneath public positions, and an understanding of how people’s personal styles or preferences influence what meaning is attributed to the actions of other stakeholders. A skilful Strategist can use this insight to shape both the cognitive meaning- making and emotional response through inspiration and vision.
Key insights from our research include the importance of getting the team off to a good start, nurturing a healthy and sustainable work culture, a collaborative culture that is underpinned by contracts that support the desired culture, and create an inclusive and motivating team narrative.
A project-as-conversation perspective foregrounds the subtle dynamics at play, for example in balancing a culture where the team goes the extra mile without creating a brutal and unsustainable, non-inclusive culture. To skilfully act as a Strategist may require a reshaping of the bigger system in which the team sits. It may require taking multiple perspectives to see how to get the work done without burning out the team. And it may require judgement calls in the face of cognitive and emotional ambiguity and uncertainty.
Governance must be re-imagined, avoiding the pretence that higher certainty can be imposed on a project in a volatile, uncertain, complex and ambiguous context than is actually possible. Part of this involves seeing the clarification of purpose, planned outcomes, benefits and priorities as sense-giving activities of the project. This broadens the relationship with a project team to assess and maintain alignment of purpose on an ongoing ‘sense-and-respond’ basis. This moves governance beyond compliance and involves consideration of ethical and societal expectations, differentiating a ‘do right project’ from a ‘do project right’ mindset.
These shifts relate to acting as a Strategist focused on orchestrating strategic conversations across relevant stakeholders, sense-making, seeing bigger pictures, creating a context for success, and seeing such success from a broader benefits and outcome realisation perspective.
A traditional view of project success that is limited to quality, cost, and time, creates an overly narrow evaluation of success. However, the selection of broader success measures can be highly political, particularly for complex public projects. As a result, a leader of complex projects must be able to align or balance the needs of multiple stakeholders with varied expectations. Also, the absence of simple and objective indicators of success means that project success is negotiated in the stakeholders’ discourse.
A Strategist would expect a fair amount of reshaping or re-baselining of a project along broader success measures and orchestrate a conversation with stakeholders to ensure they come along on that journey. While there is no disregard for budgets, timelines or quality, their focus is on how these affect the conversation regarding a project’s success, particularly what it means for the perceived contribution to a broader strategic purpose or social good.
This executive summary is from the Project Leadership; The game changer in large scale complex projects report released in June 2019.
This report is based on the Roundtable series in 2018 builds on previous themes through its focus on Project Leadership as the game changer in large scale complex projects. Combining the complementary expertise of International Centre for Complex Project Management (ICCPM) and its Series Partner, the John Grill Centre for Project Leadership, this report examines the important topic of leadership of large scale complex projects.
Roundtable workshop participants were asked to consider the leadership paradigm shifts that are needed to successfully deliver large scale complex projects. This report is the distillation of the contributions from events held across Australia, Canada and the UK. It draws on the experience of the participants and the expertise of ICCPM and the Series Partner, The John Grill Centre for Project Leadership, to present insights that individuals and organisations can use to improve their project performance.
Dr Maurizio Floris, Director of Leadership Programs, John Grill Centre for Project Leadership
Collin Smith, Managing Director & Chief Executive Officer, International Centre for Complex Project Management
Professor Suresh Cuganesan, Chief Executive Officer, John Grill Centre for Project Leadership