Skip to main content
Opinion_

Coffee companion: how that muffin or banana bread adds to your waistline

19 October 2015
A small sweet snack can be a major contributor to your daily energy intake

PhD student Kathy Chapman has contributed to an analysis of the saturated fat, energy and sugars in some of our favourite treats. 

Whether it’s a coffee in hand as we walk through the office door, or a way to beat the 3pm slump, many of us rely on our local barista to get us through our working day. Australians consume a total of 16.3 million cups of coffee each day.

But while it’s easy to adjust your daily energy intake to account for the 300 kilojoules in your small skim latte, the snack you grab on the side – or the coffee alternative – could be using up to half your daily kilojoule (kJ) allowance.

Our latest study looked at drinks and sweet snacks in five coffee chains that combined have more than 2,000 stores around Australia: McCafé, Gloria Jean’s, Michel’s Patisserie, The Coffee Club and Muffin Break. If you can’t go past the banana bread, pastries, muffins and cakes, it’s likely you’re consuming too much energy, saturated fat and sugars.

Daily energy allowance

The Australian Dietary Guidelines recommend we limit the intake of saturated fat, salt, sugars and alcohol, and eat according to our energy needs to maintain a healthy weight.

Fast food outlets, bakeries and coffee and doughnut chains in New South Wales, the ACT and South Australia are required to place the kilojoule content on their menu boards and prominently feature the average adult daily energy intake of 8,700kJ.

This figure is approximately how many kJ an “average” adult needs each day to maintain weight, but this varies according to your age, height, sex and level of physical activity. You can find the the approximate number of kilojoules you need in a day by using this calculator.

Eating just 500 kilojoules extra a day for a year and not compensating by doing more exercise could mean a weight gain of almost five kilograms over a year.

Fast energy

Taking a closer look at the offerings at the five coffee chains, we found one-third of cold coffee-style drinks, two-thirds of sweet snacks and almost half the large hot flavoured drinks had more than 1,800kJ or 20% of the recommended daily intake of energy per portion.

Some sweet snacks such as Muffin Break’s double choc jumbo cookie and Coffee Club’s mudcake had more than 3,600kJ or 40% of the recommended daily energy intake.

Energy contained in foods 

Some hot drinks, including Muffin Break’s hot chocolate and chai latte, provided almost 50% of the daily intake of saturated fat.

Iced coffee and chocolate drinks are notorious for their cream and ice cream, and are often found in super-sized portions. Four of the cold drinks had more than an entire day’s intake of saturated fat and 16 had more than 50% of the recommended daily intake. The Coffee Club’s iced coffee had 39g of saturated fat (163% of the recommended daily intake) and McCafé’s coffee kick frappe had almost 20g of saturated fat.

Saturated fats in food

Eight cakes provided over 100% (and 16% of sweet snacks provided over 50%) of the daily intake of saturated fat. This included croissants (52-65% of the recommended daily intake) and jumbo cookies (69-94%).

Over half (54%) the cold beverages and 16% of the sweet snacks had more than half the daily intake of sugars. Coffee Club’s mudcake had the equivalent of 21 teaspoons of sugar and a Gloria Jeans iced coffee had 14 teaspoons.

Sugar content

Perhaps most surprisingly for some, the humble banana bread is nowhere near as healthy as it sounds. McCafé banana bread has 2,570kJ, 30% of daily energy intake, and has 12 teaspoons of sugar.

While the study did not include independent cafés, a creamy coffee and a pastry or banana bread from your local café or bakery will likely be loaded with just as many kilojoules.

 

Eating just 500 kilojoules extra a day for a year and not compensating by doing more exercise could mean a weight gain of almost five kilograms over a year.
Kathy Chapman, PhD student

 

Healthier alternatives

The good news is that we found healthier options with lower energy, less saturated fat and sugars and smaller portion sizes. While still not a healthy food, a macaron could be a better way of getting your sugar fix with only 450kJ and three teaspoons of sugar. McCafé offered a mini muffin that has 440kJ.

But some healthier-sounding options may not be great choices. While a skim flat white is a good choice, “skim” or “low fat” does not necessarily mean low in sugar or energy. A large skim Tim Tam iced chocolate from Gloria Jeans, for instance, has 20 teaspoons of sugar.

It pays to look at the kilojoule labelling in the states where it is required by law, or in other states that have not yet made energy labelling compulsory, check out websites such as thisfor energy information.

But if you’re after a caffeine fix, you’re better off sticking with a standard flat white or skim latte, and skipping the cake on the side.

Poor diet and excess weight increase the risk of developing a number of chronic diseases and ten cancers, including bowel, endometrial and post-menopausal breast cancer. Almost 4,000 cancers diagnosed in Australia each year are linked to excess weight and obesity.

Our study did not collect consumption data but the latest information on what Australians are eating shows that just over one-third (35%) of total energy consumed was from “discretionary” junk foods and drinks.

Spending on high-energy fast food and eating out increased by 50% from 2003 to 2010. But while much of the scrutiny of fast food chains is on those providing meals, there has also been a rise in the number and popularity of coffee chains.

To help Australians make better dietary choices, we’re calling on coffee chains to provide smaller, healthier portion sizes across their drink and snack ranges. They should also address the levels of unhealthy nutrients in their snacks and drinks by reformulating menu items to reduce saturated fat, sugar and energy content.

There’s no need to cut these drinks and snacks out of your diet altogether, but next time you pop out for a coffee, consider how many kilojoules you’re consuming and what you’re prepared to go without later.

Kathy Chapman is doing a PhD in the Faculty of Science's School of Molecular Bioscience. An extended version of this piece appears on The Conversation. Wendy Watson, Nutrition Project Officer, and Clare Hughes, Nutrition Program Manager, both at Cancer Council NSW contributed to this article.

Verity Leatherdale

Manager, Faculty Media and PR
Address
  • Level 2 Services Building G12

Related articles

13 August 2015

Resetting the table to halt expanding waistlines

Can farmers, producers and regulators work together at all points of the food supply chain to help curb Australia’s growing obesity problem?

13 August 2015

How mobile phones could save us from obesity

A world-first intervention designed by Charles Perkins Centre researchers specifically for young people found mobile phones could improve health and halt weight gain. 

13 August 2015

Sydney’s cyclists twice as happy as other commuters: new research

Sydney’s commuting cyclists are twice as happy as people who drive, walk or use public transport to get to work, University of Sydney research reveals.

27 August 2015

Athletes score for disability and donors

Wheelchair basketball athletes from the NSW Institute of Sport and Wheelchair Sports NSW showed their support for the Pave the Way campaign this week.    

14 August 2015

Scientists should take a leaf out of wellness bloggers' books

How can we distinguish credible wellness information from unfounded pseudoscience? And why is it that wellness gurus are often taken more seriously than scientists? Jackie Randles writes.

24 August 2015

Choosing children’s sex is an exercise in sexism

The review of Australian guidelines for the ethical use of IVF is raising questions over the impact of sex selection for non-medical purposes. Dr Tereza Hendl writes in The Conversation.

25 August 2015

Preventing dementia

Eighty percent of people with dementia risk factors will develop the disease within five years.

19 August 2015

Surge in flu this winter

People suffering severe flu this winter should seek medical treatment as soon as possible.

19 August 2015

Health Check: the low-down on standing desks

Five things you should know before getting a standing desk, writes Josephine Chau and Lina Engelen 

06 August 2015

Mindfulness therapy alleviates PTSD, but only in the short term

Mindfulness-based stress reduction therapy produces a sharp decline in the severity of post-traumatic stress disorder symptoms, writes Ian Hickie and Jane Burns.