Skip to main content
News_

Surgeons take a scalpel to their own toxic culture

11 September 2015
Culture of bullying, sexual harassment widespread among surgeons, report reveals

Privilege is often invisible to those who have it, writes University of Sydney academic Dr Kimberley Ivory.

An independent report commissioned by the Royal Australasian College of Surgeons (RACS) released yesterday has found bullying, sexual harassment and discrimination are commonplace in the culture of surgeons. 

Apologising and committing to genuine action to address the a €œtoxic culture€ is a positive step, but the actual detox will require more radical surgery to some deeply held beliefs and a transplant of new attitudes about who is, and what it is to be, a doctor.

After reading news of the report in the morning, I found myself later in the day listening to a second-year medical student - let'€™s call her Jessica - describe the humiliating bedside teaching methods of a female clinician she's nicknamed €œThe Trunchbull€*.

She said: "The most offensive part was that this all occurred in front of patients. You could even see the looks on the patients'€™ faces, willing us to get the questions right, as they knew the humiliation that was to ensue."

We already know that 74% of Jessica'€™s peers have had similar experiences. And we now know that if her training leads her down the surgical path, there's a 58% chance Jessica will continue to be bullied and a 30% chance she will be sexually abused or assaulted. This figure is tragically in line with the 33% chance of such abuse described in earlier studies.

And we know that if Jessica chooses to take action against her tormentors, she faces a 30% chance it will continue unabated.

Toxic culture

The events of this year have left no doubt the culture of medical training in Australia is toxic. That toxicity is killing doctors and it'€™s killing patients.

The release of the RACS report was accompanied by contrition and an apology from the college about its own part in enabling this toxic culture€ to flourish. But demanding cultural change is one thing. Achieving it is quite another.

The college should be congratulated for taking the essential first step towards cultural change: acknowledging the existence and scope of the problem. They'€™ve also identified that there are still some surgeons who don't believe these problems exist.

This mirrors much of the commentary of denial and victim-blaming around this issue in recent months. The deniers say, "It didn'€™t happen to me, therefore it doesn'€™t happen."€ The victim-blamers suggest trainees are "€œwhingers"€ and need to toughen up, or that they'€™re using their €"feminine wiles"€ to get ahead.

Despite accepting all the report'€™s recommendations unequivocally, the next step for the RACS is much harder. It requires not just a new willingness to hold surgeons to account against revised policies and procedures, but also a frank scrutiny of the culture itself, especially its institutionalised norms and privileges.

Social exclusion

There's a disturbing similarity between the statistics about negative health outcomes and experiences of abuse in medicine to those seen in other populations that experience high levels of social exclusion. Two notable examples are Indigenous Australians and people from sexual and gender minorities. Social exclusion - the negative consequence of stigma and discrimination - causes mental distress, substance abuse, reduced access to health care and poorer health outcomes.

Surely doctors, especially surgeons, are not a marginalised or stigmatised group? They'€™re revered, trusted and highly valued by society. Actually, what matters most within a culture is not how doctors are perceived by society, but how they perceive each other. And within the society of doctors, not all doctors are equal.

Medicine today is a complex, increasingly diverse, but still very hierarchical culture. But as recently as the mid-20th century, it was much more mono-cultural: predominantly white, Caucasian, affluent, heterosexual and male. That is no longer the case.

In 2012, three out of five employed doctors were men, but the number of women graduating is increasing at a greater rate than men. By 2025, 42% of the medical workforce will be female. About one-third of doctors received their original qualification in a country other than Australia and the average age of Australian doctors was 46.

But despite their significant numbers at graduation, women still make up only about 25% of the specialist workforce and only 24% of those are in surgical specialities. Even with increasing diversity, the dominant medical culture in Australia remains skewed against the young, the female and the foreign.

The nature of privilege

To understand how a privileged group can be marginalised, we first have to understand privilege: the advantages available to members of the dominant group, such as resources and power, that are not available to others. To an outsider, that would look like all doctors. But insiders know "€œsome doctors are more equal than others"€.

Doctors are an "in group"€. Within "in groups", we recognise other members as being diverse individuals, but we also measure them against their conformity with the dominant cultural norms of the group. Younger women and people with diverse identities, in particular, risk falling short of the prevailing standard despite their medical competency.

Privilege is often invisible to those who have it and they have a vested interest in keeping it that way. It'€™s invisible because it constitutes what the group deems as "€œnormal"€ or "€œordinary"€ - and so it remains unexamined. Those who have it are often unable to see that others do not, or blame those who do not as somehow deficient or to blame for their situation rather than critically examining their own.

Once privilege is established, it'€™s not even necessary for individuals to actively oppress others. The institutionalisation of cultural norms effectively reinforces the exclusion of non-conformers and also makes it difficult for them to challenge their oppressors.

Medicine is not alone among Australian workplaces in its experience of bullying and harassment, but the stakes are higher there. Students like Jessica fail to learn, individual competency and work performance are affected, team morale declines and ultimately patient safety is threatened.

The time for talking is over. The results are in. Yes, the problem is real. The authors of the RACS report note: "Long-established traditions that have been inherited and have normalised unprofessional, and sometimes illegal, behaviours must be relinquished ... Everyone involved in the practice of surgery ... has a role in leading the way."

The process of change will be similarly slow and as painful as breaking down the institutionalised discrimination against Indigenous and sexual and gender minority people. But it will happen. In the meantime, none of us - neither doctors, other health workers, nor patients - can remain silent or pretend to be innocent bystanders.

This article was first published in The Conversation.

*Miss Agatha Trunchbull, also known simply as "the Trunchbull", is the fictional bullying headmistress of Crunchem Hall Primary School and main antagonist in Roald Dahl's book, Matilda.

Related articles

23 June 2016

Australia 20 years after gun reform: no mass shootings, declining firearm deaths

Since major gun law reform 20 years ago, Australia has seen no mass shootings and an accelerating decline in intentional firearm deaths, the Journal of the American Medical Association reports today.

23 June 2016

New insights into the causes of sudden cardiac death in the young revealed

Sudden cardiac death claims the lives of 2-3 young Australians every week. 

28 June 2016

Are itchier insect bites more likely to make us sick?

New research suggests the worse our reactions to mosquito bites are, the more likely it is we’ll get sick, says Dr Cameron Webb.

15 June 2016

How can we make sense of the Orlando shooting?

As the world mourns the tragic loss of 50 lives, how can we answer the questions around homophobia and mental health raised by the Orlando shooting? Our researchers appeared on ABC’s The Drum to discuss the complex debate. 

13 December 2016

Confidence boost linked to weight loss in smartphone trial

Confidence is key when motivating young people to change their diet and exercise habits, new research from the University of Sydney shows.

13 December 2016

Sydney alum off to Stanford as Monash scholar

University of Sydney alumnus Dr Martin Seneviratne has been named the 2017 Roden Cutler NSW John Monash Scholar. The award will see Dr Seneviratne head to Stanford University to continue his ground-breaking work into clinical informatics.

14 December 2016

Brain structure best explains our dwindling tolerance of risk

Nature findings will improve understanding of decision-making, as global demographics shift toward an aged population. 

14 December 2016

Exotic mosquitoes a clear and present danger for Australians

Fears of outbreaks of Zika and dengue due to Australian travellers visiting affected countries this summer.

08 December 2016

Minister Ley launches Psychology clinics in Brain and Mind Centre

Federal Health and Aged Care Minister Sussan Ley today launched the one-stop-shop psychology, psychiatry and neuroscience clinics, touring the new facilities leading the way in multidisciplinary brain and mind care.

12 December 2016

Child mummy offers revised history of smallpox

A child mummy from the 17th century, found in a crypt underneath a Lithuanian church, was discovered to harbour the oldest known sample of the variola virus that causes smallpox.